Searching High and Low: Prosodic Breaks Disambiguate Relative Clauses
نویسندگان
چکیده
During natural speech perception, listeners rely on a wide range of cues to support comprehension, from semantic context to prosodic information. There is a general consensus that prosody plays a role in syntactic parsing, but most studies focusing on ambiguous relative clauses (RC) show that prosodic cues, alone, are insufficient to reverse the preferred interpretation of sentence. These findings suggest that universally preferred structures (e.g., Late Closure principle) matter far more than prosodic cues in such cases. This study explores an alternative hypothesis: that the weak effect of prosody might be due to the influence of various syntactic, lexical-semantic, and acoustic confounding factors, and investigate the consequences of prosodic breaks while controlling these variables. We used Spanish RC sentences in three experimental conditions where the presence and position (following the first or second noun phrase) of prosodic breaks was manipulated. The results showed that the placement of a prosodic break determined sentence interpretation by changing the preferred attachment of the RC. Listeners' natural preference for low attachment (in the absence of break) was reinforced when a prosodic break was placed after the first noun. In contrast, a prosodic break placed after the second noun reversed the preferred interpretation of the sentence, toward high attachment. We argue that, in addition to other factors, listeners indeed use prosodic breaks as robust cues to syntactic parsing during speech processing, as these cues may direct listeners toward one interpretation or another.
منابع مشابه
The Prosody of Algebra and the Algebra of Prosody: Prosodic Disambiguation of Read Mathematical Formulae
Read mathematical formulae (MF) provide an ideal and littlestudied window into speakers' ability to prosodically disambiguate complex NPs. An experiment investigating whether and how speakers of different mathematical skill levels prosodically mark English utterances containing ambiguities caused by the application of unary and binary mathematical operators found that speakers consistently mark...
متن کاملUse of Prosody in Syntactic Disambiguation: An Analysis-by-Synthesis Approach
of seven types of structural ambiguity. In addition, it ap~ ~ ~ ~ f i ~ ~ t ~ have shown that prosody is used by human ]ispeared that the relative size and location of prosodic phrase teners to disambiguate spoken language and, in particular, that boundaries provided the principal prosodic clue for resolvthe relative size and location of prosodic phrase boundaries proing ambiguities. Thus, it s...
متن کاملProsodic phrasing modeling for vietnamese TTS using syntactic information
This research aims at modeling prosodic phrasing for improving the naturalness of Vietnamese (a tonal language) speech synthesis. The proposed phrasing model includes hypotheses on: (i) prosodic structure based on syntactic rules (ii) final lengthening linked to syllabic structures and tone types. Audio files in the analysis corpus are manually transcribed at the syllable level and perceived pa...
متن کاملLearning of relative clauses by L3 learners of English
In surveys of third language acquisition (TLA) research, mixed results demonstrate that there is no consensus among researchers regarding the advantages and/or disadvantages of bilinguality on TLA. The main concern of the present study was, thus, to probe the probable differences between Persian monolingual and Azeri-Persian bilingual learners of English regarding their...
متن کاملCat.Jour.Ling. 2 001-283
Our investigation focuses on several types of structural ambiguity in European Portuguese. The materials include sentences with set-divider adverbs ambiguous as to the direction of syntactic attachment, adjunct and complement PPs ambiguous as to the level of syntactic embedding, nonrestrictive clauses with local and non-local possible antecedents, and relative clauses ambiguous as to their rest...
متن کامل